GORUCK Rucks Discussion

[Hawkman]

I've searched around the forum for some information on whether or not a waist strap is beneficial/necessary part of a ruck (to be used for SFAS preparation). I came across a thread entitled 'Rucking - Cutting Waist Strap' where the general consensus is a waist strap does offer support and can prevent injury, even though some have rucked without one with no consequences.

Now to GORUCK, their events have been popular for the past few years, and they sell high-quality rucks...without waist straps. From the website, these packs look very good, and can take a beating. GORUCK does recommend one their brand of packs for their events. It is important to note that Jason McCarthy (founder of GORUCK) was a 10th Grouper.

So my question is this: How necessary is a waist strap for rucksack marching? If the answer is 'very necessary' where does that put GORUCK rucks? Are these packs truly meant to be rucked in, or are they more of a 1-day pack/BOB?

Not trying to stir up any dissention--I think GORUCK is an great brand and organization. I am simply interested in your thoughts.

Thanks for the input!