How can any discussion of the best and worst presdients be held without mention of LBJ? Twice the social programs of FDR with none of the wartime leadership. FDR may have started the wheels turning on the giant goverment entitlement program bus, but LBJ got that sucker going at mach 1...not sure we'll ever recover from it, either.
I always thought James Monroe (with help from JQ Adams) was underrated. That Mondroe Doctrine thing worked out pretty well.
Like James Madison, too. More for what he did prior to entering the office, though.
Would agree with most on the Reagan, Washington, Lincoln, T Roosevelt bit. GW Bush gets a second term and continues to prosecute the WoT as he's done so far, and methinks he'll make the all time list.
Lincoln as one of the worst presidents? Man, that's just funny...or sad...I can't tell which.