View Single Post
Old 02-22-2004, 22:58   #40
HQ6
Guerrilla
 
HQ6's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Where the heart is
Posts: 257
All in one answer/questions

Quote:
Originally posted by The Reaper
Molon Labe!

If you catch me, you can have me.
Promises... Promises.

Quote:
Originally posted by Surgicalcric
I dont think it should matter whether or not a person is born here.

If a person takes up arms against their own countrymen they do not deserve the rights afforded them under The Constitution.
RL beat me to the punch. If we strip citizens of their Constitutional rights before due process, then what good is the Constitution? If we can go around willy nilly and deny rights to people we think are terrorists, I have a list for you. It starts with a cake baker by the name of...

Quote:
Originally posted by The Reaper
Born here, specific number of years of satisfactory residency, followed by a citizenship test, or military service, like we do for adults?

Limited citizenship rights till then.
TR has an interesting point. It is kind of Starship Troopers -ish. I like it. Why should we get these rights just because the place of our birth is geographically desirable?

However, to put a crinkle in your plan, what is to stop an individual from being breed in this county, raised a model citizen, and even joining the military or civil service as a rouse to gain access to rights that only citizens do have? What then?

Or were you suggesting that we take a citizenship test at 18 years-old? Something similar to a driver's license?

Quote:
Originally posted by myclearcreek
Those who defended themselves?
That would be the Southern States, right?
__________________
Moglie del Soldato
HQ6 is offline   Reply With Quote