Professional Soldiers ®

Professional Soldiers ® (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/index.php)
-   Special Forces Assessment & Selection (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   DISCOVERY CHANNEL - SFAS (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=26593)

Slantwire 12-22-2009 10:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by JoelBlack (Post 303635)
On the star navigation course, a candidate was walking on the road which is against the rules (roadkill). When he got caught the SF assessor asked the candidate for his roster number. The candidate shot his cluster flare at the cadre and escape into the tree line. Now when everyone returned to the RV candidates were asked to show their clusters. One might think this would ruin ones SF career, but he was allowed to continue his interview. The reason being.... Thinking outside of the box. Thats the kind of stuff SF look for. He also received a major minus.:D

That story was pretty universally known among the 18X candidates in 2007. It seemed it happened in the class before the storyteller's buddy, no matter which class that buddy had been in.

BryanK 12-22-2009 12:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by jdl141 (Post 303555)
Unfortunatley I missed the show last night. I've been looking all over for when they might replay it but with no luck. Does anybody have any info about when it might be coming on again?

Thanks.

I emailed Discovery, and this is what they replied (I missed it as well):

Dear Viewer,

Thank you for contacting Discovery Channel.

Two Weeks In Hell is currently scheduled to re-air on January 14th at 8
p.m. EST.

For programming and schedule information, please visit our website at
www.discovery.com, then click on TV Schedule. Our schedules are published
for the current and following month. If you are not able to locate the
programming you are looking for, we recommend checking back periodically to
see if it has been added to the current schedule.

For your convenience, use the "Newsletters" feature on our website to
receive e-mail reminders letting you know when your favorite program is
going to be televised.


Sincerely,

Viewer Relations
Discovery Channel

HTH

freelander 12-22-2009 12:31

Question to the QPs...

No rank, no HOAHs, but during team week, are candidates drawn to the inclination to pull the rank card in situations where shit has hit the fan and no one has any control? Team 4 was ok according to the cadre and then the good idea fairly came in and jacked it up. IOW, people wanted to input their .02 and contribute to the confusion as a result. If a candidate was tapped as PL and made it known that his decisions would stand and he alone would be accountable for them, how would that go down in SFAS? Also, do senior NCOs or officers announce themselves quietly and naturally stand out or is that discouraged?

Correct me if I am wrong, which I probably am, but it would seem that those with leadership experience would on average, be able to untangle team 4 type situations and thus accomplish the mission.

Thank you for your service and time.

18C Troll 12-22-2009 12:37

sfas stories
 
Sounds like the story in my class, except he ran into the woods and when the Cadre asked for his roster number all he heard was an e-tool squeking open. Same stories differant times.

Utah Bob 12-22-2009 13:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by greenberetTFS (Post 303077)
I'm glad I'm old and never had to experience it at all..................:rolleyes:

Big Teddy :munchin

Ditto!:D

TrapLine 12-22-2009 14:29

I enjoyed watching the show and the glimpse it gave into the process of becoming a QP. As others have pointed out, while I was watching I thought that the show might reveal a lot to upcoming students and wondered if it could hurt the process. I almost kicked myself when I reminded myself who was teaching the class. Something tells me the cadre have a pretty big bag of tricks. Finally, I could not help but wonder if some of the cadre featured walk the halls of ps.com.

Jasf10 12-22-2009 14:41

Quote:

Originally Posted by freelander (Post 303679)
Question to the QPs...

No rank, no HOAHs, but during team week, are candidates drawn to the inclination to pull the rank card in situations where shit has hit the fan and no one has any control? Team 4 was ok according to the cadre and then the good idea fairly came in and jacked it up. IOW, people wanted to input their .02 and contribute to the confusion as a result. If a candidate was tapped as PL and made it known that his decisions would stand and he alone would be accountable for them, how would that go down in SFAS? Also, do senior NCOs or officers announce themselves quietly and naturally stand out or is that discouraged?

I like that there was no rank and the no Hooahs. "Hooah" can get really annoying. "Hooah" what they teach you in basic training..."don't think, just say hooah".

No rank helps to avoid credentialism.

I wonder if the guy that lost his weapon got selected? :eek:

Utah Bob 12-22-2009 15:53

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Reaper (Post 303648)
Sometimes, people tell stories that are not factual or may have been embellished.

TR

Very diplomatically put. :D
Who said talking to G chiefs doesn't give you valuable experience in tactful, interpersonal communications. :D

Some of us tend to blurt out, "Oh Bullshit!";)

Surgicalcric 12-22-2009 16:05

Quote:

Originally Posted by freelander (Post 303679)
...are candidates drawn to the inclination to pull the rank card in situations where shit has hit the fan and no one has any control...

Show up and find out.

We are not going to give away all the keys to the process...

Crip

Team Sergeant 12-22-2009 16:32

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jasf10 (Post 303716)
I like that there was no rank and the no Hooahs. "Hooah" can get really annoying. "Hooah" what they teach you in basic training..."don't think, just say hooah".

No rank helps to avoid credentialism.

I wonder if the guy that lost his weapon got selected? :eek:

What's a "hooah" ???

I will tell you having served 20 years I never said "hooah"......:rolleyes: Then again I never used the word "operator" when referring to Special Forces soldiers.

Costa 12-22-2009 17:15

I still can't believe kids were bringing contraband like ripped fuel and thinking they could get away with it. I couldn't help but think- What idiots!

Surgicalcric 12-22-2009 17:31

Quote:

Originally Posted by deepblack 18x (Post 303763)
What does ripped fuel do?


Google not working?

Crip

The Reaper 12-22-2009 20:49

There are people posting on this thread that are excellent examples of why we have a selection and assessment process.

Some of you would probably be on the truck headed back to Bragg before the first 24 hours were passed.

Trust me, after watching over 40 classes, you get a sense of these things.

TR


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:35.


Copyright 2004-2022 by Professional Soldiers ®