Professional Soldiers ®

Professional Soldiers ® (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/index.php)
-   Special Forces Assessment & Selection (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   DISCOVERY CHANNEL - SFAS (http://www.professionalsoldiers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=26593)

longrange1947 12-21-2009 20:28

Yeah, I too missed the show due to head up fourth point of contact. Will have to go to Mackall and see the changes. Went through in 67-68, did not even know what a retest or recycle was then, and know a few changes happened when I was last there in 96. Heard the place is unrecognizable from what I remember.

lksteve 12-21-2009 20:30

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Reaper (Post 303563)
The Discovery Channel is showing on their website that it will air tonight at 2300. YMMV.

Actually, MMDV...my schedule shows "Who was Jesus"...it shows 2 Weeks in hell was on last night at 2300...

JoelBlack 12-22-2009 02:32

Quote:

Good program.

Too much yelling, IMHO.

TR

I recorded Two Weeks in Hell and let my brother, a RI down at 6th RTB for swamp phase, watch it and he said that the SF assessors did not yell one bit. They stood there with there arms crossed not saying a word. He said they were probably doing that for the cameras.

I quote word for word his exact comment....."I can't believe they're documenting this!"

olhamada 12-22-2009 08:01

I watched this last night (DVR) and couldn't believe one of my best friend's little brothers was front and center several times as a candidate. I knew "Caleb" made it, but it was a nice surprise to see him in the pit, on the STAR Course, and at the white board. I hadn't realized that he was there during the filming.

I also couldn't believe "they" allowed this to be documented, but thought it was very well done, still left a lot to the imagination, and showed how few really make it.

Streck-Fu 12-22-2009 08:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by JoelBlack (Post 303613)
He said they were probably doing that for the cameras.

I guess there isn't enough drama for most American audiences unless there's a bunch of yelling going on. I would prefer to see it as it actually is. I think most of the people interested in watching it, would feel the same way.

Perhaps the yelling draws in a few more channel surfers.

US Patriot 12-22-2009 08:12

Great show the other night. Saw one of my friends that I ride bikes with. Was cool that I knew someone from there. You guys do a great job and I hold you all in high regard. Thanks for all you do and the sacrifices you make. Keep up the hard work..

The Reaper 12-22-2009 08:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by JoelBlack (Post 303613)
I recorded Two Weeks in Hell and let my brother, a RI down at 6th RTB for swamp phase, watch it and he said that the SF assessors did not yell one bit. They stood there with there arms crossed not saying a word. He said they were probably doing that for the cameras.

I quote word for word his exact comment....."I can't believe they're documenting this!"

Actually, more of them appeared to be using their Air Force hand warmers than crossing their arms.

Pretty funny when you see someone chewing ass with their hands in their pockets.

TR

JoelBlack 12-22-2009 08:46

thinking outside the box
 
On the star navigation course, a candidate was walking on the road which is against the rules (roadkill). When he got caught the SF assessor asked the candidate for his roster number. The candidate shot his cluster flare at the cadre and escape into the tree line. Now when everyone returned to the RV candidates were asked to show their clusters. One might think this would ruin ones SF career, but he was allowed to continue his interview. The reason being.... Thinking outside of the box. Thats the kind of stuff SF look for. He also received a major minus.:D

Counsel 12-22-2009 08:56

Quote:

Originally Posted by armymom1228 (Post 303522)
I cringed when the commentator asked if there had ever been any women QP's.
I was thrilled to see they sidestepped that pandora's box nicely.

You were not the only one that thought that. :D

The Reaper 12-22-2009 08:58

Quote:

Originally Posted by JoelBlack (Post 303635)
On the star navigation course, a candidate was walking on the road which is against the rules (roadkill). When he got caught the SF assessor asked the candidate for his roster number. The candidate shot his cluster flare at the cadre and escape into the tree line. Now when everyone returned to the RV candidates were asked to show their clusters. One might think this would ruin ones SF career, but he was allowed to continue his interview. The reason being.... Thinking outside of the box. Thats the kind of stuff SF look for. He also received a major minus.:D

Where did you hear this story?

Just FYI, it is pretty hard for a tired, worn-out student with a rubber weapon, GPS locator, a reflective vest, and 50-70 pounds on his back to run into the woods blindly and escape from a freshly rested cadre member who knows the AO intimately, is carrying no load, has access to an ATV, and who is wearing NVGs.

TR

Richard 12-22-2009 09:05

Quote:

Where did you hear this story?
Right up there with reindeer antlers - shoulda run it by Snopes or PolitiFactcheck first! :p

Richard

JoelBlack 12-22-2009 09:11

Quote:

Where did you hear this story?

Just FYI, it is pretty hard for a tired, worn-out student with a rubber weapon, GPS locator, a reflective vest, and 50-70 pounds on his back to run into the woods blindly and escape from a freshly rested cadre member who knows the AO intimately with no load and wearing NVGs.
My thoughts exactly...

Brother went through a year and half ago. I recorded and watch it with him last night and when a candidate had got caught on the road he pointed at the screen and told me the story.

Maybe escape is not the correct wording... Blatantly walked into the tree line.

BRAVO-SMASH 12-22-2009 09:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by JoelBlack (Post 303641)
My thoughts exactly...

Brother went through a year and half ago. I recorded and watch it with him last night and when a candidate had got caught on the road he pointed at the screen and told me the story. He stated the cadre most likely did not give chase.

Didnt know they gave major minus at selection :rolleyes:... Yeah, I dont think they do.

The Reaper 12-22-2009 09:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by JoelBlack (Post 303641)
My thoughts exactly...

Brother went through a year and half ago. I recorded and watch it with him last night and when a candidate had got caught on the road he pointed at the screen and told me the story.

Maybe escape is not the correct wording... Blatantly walked into the tree line.

Sometimes, people tell stories that are not factual or may have been embellished.

While I was dealing with SFAS, if you were a roadkill who fired pyro at a cadre member and tried to escape, you would have been run down, thumped, out of the course, NTRed, and recommended for UCMJ pretty quickly.

I am formally throwing the BS flag on this one. Will be more than happy to call the cadre and inquire on your brother's behalf, if you want.

TR

Surgicalcric 12-22-2009 10:02

Quote:

Originally Posted by JoelBlack (Post 303635)
...Thinking outside of the box. Thats the kind of stuff SF look for...

I love hearing people talk about "thinking outside the box." It seems those who talk the most are those who cant manage to think inside the box, attempting to use it as a defense for poorly thought out ideas/decisions...

Also, I would hold off on deciding what it is we are looking for until such time you understand a lil more about us.


Crip


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 18:16.


Copyright 2004-2022 by Professional Soldiers ®